As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
On The Table Read Magazine, “the best entertainment eBook magazine UK“, discover the top 10 true crime podcasts of 2025, from gripping investigations to witty scams, perfect for thrilling your commute or cozy nights in!
True crime podcasts have taken the world by storm, offering gripping narratives, deep dives into unsolved mysteries, and thought-provoking explorations of justice and human behavior. With thousands of shows to choose from, finding the best ones can be daunting.
Here’s a curated list of the top 10 true crime podcasts in 2025, blending investigative journalism, compelling storytelling, and unique perspectives. Whether you’re a seasoned “murderino” or a curious newcomer, these podcasts will keep you hooked.
The Top 10 True Crime Podcasts
1. Serial
Why It’s Great: The podcast that launched the true crime boom, Serial remains a benchmark for the genre. Hosted by Sarah Koenig, its first season (2014) investigated the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee and the conviction of Adnan Syed, captivating millions with its meticulous reporting and narrative style. Subsequent seasons have explored other cases, including Bowe Bergdahl’s desertion and systemic issues in the justice system.
What to Expect: Long-form investigative storytelling with a focus on nuance and ambiguity. The 2024 season continues to deliver fresh perspectives.
Why It’s Top: Its cultural impact, rigorous journalism, and ability to spark real-world change (like Syed’s case reopening) make it essential listening.
2. In the Dark
Why It’s Great: This award-winning podcast, hosted by Madeleine Baran, is a masterclass in investigative journalism. Season 1 tackled the 1989 abduction of Jacob Wetterling, while Season 2 focused on Curtis Flowers, a man tried six times for the same crime. The show’s thorough reporting has led to real-world outcomes, including case reopenings.
What to Expect: Deep dives into single cases over multiple episodes, exposing systemic failures in the justice system. Season 3 (2024) explores the lives of women connected to Dubai’s ruler.
Why It’s Top: Its relentless pursuit of truth and tangible impact set it apart.
3. My Favorite Murder
Why It’s Great: Hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, My Favorite Murder blends true crime with humor and empathy, creating a loyal fanbase known as “Murderinos.” The hosts share stories of murders, disappearances, and oddities, often weaving in personal anecdotes and mental health discussions.
What to Expect: Conversational, anthology-style episodes covering famous and lesser-known cases, with a balance of sensitivity and levity.
Why It’s Top: Its relatable hosts and community-driven approach make it a comforting yet thrilling listen.
4. Casefile
Why It’s Great: Hosted by an anonymous Australian narrator, Casefile delivers meticulously researched stories with a focus on the facts. Covering everything from serial killers to missing persons, it avoids sensationalism while maintaining a gripping narrative.
What to Expect: Single-case episodes with detailed timelines and respectful storytelling. The anonymity of the host keeps the focus on the victims and cases.
Why It’s Top: Its global scope and commitment to ethical storytelling appeal to serious true crime fans.
5. Bone Valley
Why It’s Great: This standout podcast, hosted by Pulitzer Prize winner Gilbert King, investigates the case of Leo Schofield, who served 35 years for a murder he likely didn’t commit. The show uncovers evidence pointing to another suspect and even solves an unrelated murder along the way.
What to Expect: A single-season, immersive investigation with compelling evidence and emotional depth.
Why It’s Top: Its rigorous research and ability to indict institutional failures make it a must-listen.
6. Your Own Backyard
Why It’s Great: Hosted by investigative journalist Chris Lambert, Your Own Backyard explores the 1996 disappearance of Cal Poly student Kristin Smart. Lambert’s dogged reporting contributed to the arrest and conviction of a suspect nearly three decades later.
What to Expect: A single-case, multi-episode journey with a focus on community impact and victim advocacy.
Why It’s Top: Its real-world impact and empathetic storytelling resonate deeply.
7. Southern Fried True Crime
Why It’s Great: Native Tennessean Erica Kelley brings a warm, storytelling vibe to this podcast, which focuses on crimes in the American South. With over 200 episodes, Kelley covers historical and contemporary cases with a Southern twang and a knack for detail.
What to Expect: Anthology-style episodes that feel like porchside gossip, blending local flavor with thorough research.
Why It’s Top: Its regional focus and Kelley’s engaging narration make it a unique addition to the genre.
8. Sistas Who Kill
Why It’s Great: Hosted by best friends MaRah and Taz, this podcast examines cases involving Black women perpetrators, highlighting disparities in the justice system. It combines well-researched narratives with discussions on social justice.
What to Expect: Anthology episodes with a focus on underrepresented stories, delivered with passion and perspective.
Why It’s Top: Its fresh angle and commitment to amplifying marginalized voices make it essential listening.
9. Up and Vanished
Why It’s Great: Hosted by Payne Lindsey, Up and Vanished brought renewed attention to cold cases like the disappearance of Tara Grinstead (Season 1). Lindsey’s investigative approach and real-time updates keep listeners engaged.
What to Expect: Multi-episode seasons focusing on single cases, with a documentary-style feel and occasional breakthroughs.
Why It’s Top: Its role in advancing cold case investigations and Lindsey’s immersive style make it a fan favorite.
10. Scam Goddess
Why It’s Great: For a lighter take on true crime, Scam Goddess, hosted by Laci Mosley, dives into financial crimes and con artists with humor and wit. From fake heiresses to corporate fraud, Mosley and her guests unpack scams with a focus on the absurd.
What to Expect: Anthology episodes blending true crime with comedy, perfect for those wanting a break from murder-heavy content.
Why It’s Top: Its unique focus on non-violent crime and Mosley’s infectious energy make it a refreshing listen.
Why True Crime Podcasts Matter
True crime podcasts do more than entertain—they shed light on systemic issues, give voice to victims, and sometimes even solve cases. From Serial’s groundbreaking storytelling to Sistas Who Kill’s focus on marginalized narratives, these shows reflect the genre’s diversity and impact. Whether you’re drawn to investigative deep dives or lighter, comedic takes, there’s something here for everyone.
Pro Tip: Many of these podcasts offer ad-free episodes or bonus content through subscriptions like Tenderfoot TV Plus or Pushkin Plus. Check their websites for details.
So, grab your headphones, dim the lights, and dive into these gripping stories. Which one will you binge first?
Note: This list is based on popularity, critical acclaim, listener feedback, and unique contributions to the genre, drawing from sources like Vogue, Forbes, and Reddit discussions. Always listen with discretion, as some content may be disturbing.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.